The mighty toaster oven is an awesome tool to have in your kitchen, and we’re sharing the best toaster ovens of 2018-2023 here. What are you making in yours next?
There’s a little song about toast that a man named Heywood Banks once wrote called “YEAH TOAST!”. It catalogs the man’s love of toast and the absurd nature of our relationship to toast. It’s an ode to one of our most treasured breakfast foods.
Toast and toaster ovens have inspired people to sing silly songs about toast in the morning for generations. And each year, toast and toasters just keep on getting better. But toaster ovens do more than just give you toast. They are ovens, by the way, and you can rely on them to bake just about anything small enough to fit in one. Which is why you need to make sure you have the best toaster oven on the block.
If your toaster oven just toasted bread, you wouldn’t be reading this article right now. But because your toaster is a cheaper alternative to a larger oven, we’ve gathered the ultimate top best toaster ovens for this year. And hopefully, by the end of this toaster oven review article, you will have enough selection to choose your favorite toaster oven so that you too can start singing about toast.
Top 10 Best Toaster Ovens of 2018-2023
10. BLACK+DECKER TO1303SB 4-Slice Toaster Oven
This oven, too, is energy efficient. At 1,150 watts it will certainly add less to your energy bill too.
It comes with a baking and a broiling function. But you will have to be careful if you want to defrost food. It doesn’t have an automatic defrost setting.
Again, you’re sacrificing the ability to heat to the specified temperature for energy efficiency. This seems to be a theme with even the best toaster ovens that are energy efficient.
Despite the fact it can’t reach the specified temperature, it does cook food evenly.
It’s light. It weighs only 7.5 lbs. So, you can easily transport it around your kitchen if things need re-arranging.
There are few safety features on this oven. It has no automatic rack ejector. You need to manually remove racks from the oven after baking.
The handle can get quite hot on this oven, so be careful. But it does have a timer and the oven does shut off after the timer runs out. So, you can just let the handle cool before touching it or use an oven mitt.
So, if you want something cheap and energy efficient that cooks food evenly go for the Black & Decker 4-Slice
9. Cuisinart TOB-40N Custom Classic Toaster Oven Broiler
This might sound like a track circuit car race, but it’s a toaster oven. We promise.
This oven in our best toaster ovens lineup features four cooking functions: Bake, broil, toast, and bagel.
This is a basic toaster oven that preheats quickly and cooks food thoroughly.
The dial puts temperatures at anywhere between 150 degrees to 450 degrees.
It will reach 350 degrees in under five and a half minutes, which is a decent speed for a toaster oven.
It is an upgrade as far as toast slice capacity goes. Our previous two ovens could fit four slices, while the Cuisinart Custom Classic can fit 6 slices.
And, what’s more, this toaster oven can keep the temperature at the promised rate. Set it at 350 degrees and cook your food at 350 degrees. No questions asked.
It weighs in at thirteen pounds. Which is a little heavy, but still easy to move around. Plus it features an automatic rack ejector so you don’t have to use an oven mitt to keep your hands from burning.
If you want a toaster oven that’s efficient and cooks thoroughly at the correct temperature, but don’t have a ton to spend. This is one of the best toaster ovens you could buy.
8. DeLonghi DO1289 Digital Convection Toaster Oven
This oven wins our silver medal because of its energy efficiency coupled with an ability to cook two racks at the same time.
No other toaster we’ve reviewed has these two features combined.
It’s certainly one of our most versatile ovens in the lineup as well. Who could imagine a toaster oven that also serves as a food dehydrator?
That’s right. The DeLonghi is both a convection toaster oven and a dehydrator.
It runs 180 to 450 degrees. It weighs 14.7 lbs. And it has a two-hour timer with an automatic shutoff.
If you can afford this beauty, then this convection toaster oven will serve all your baking and dehydrating needs.
7. Nostalgia RTOV220RETRORED
Do you have a kitchen theme which is somewhat retro or old-fashioned? Then this may be the toaster oven for you.
The Nostalgia RTOV220 Retro Toaster Oven has four heat selectors, a feature that will allow you to heat the selected heating bar. If you want your bread toasted on only one side, then you can select the lower heating mode. Need to melt cheese on top without toasting the other part? Select the upper heating. The upper and lower heating will ensure your meal will get fully cooked from inside to outside.
Accommodating up to two 12” pizzas or equivalent to 6 slices of toasts, this toaster oven comes with a non-stick aluminum baking pan and two nickel-plated racks.
6. Hamilton Beach 31104 Countertop Oven
All of the best toaster ovens on this site are incredible. And if you’re looking for an oven that is cost effective and energy efficient, you’ve found your oven.
The Hamilton Beach 31104’s internal dimensions are listed as 20.62 x 16.54 x 13.11 in., meaning you should have more than enough space to do cooking of all shapes and sizes.
It’s small enough that it can comfortably sit on your countertop, but large enough that you shouldn’t have a problem cooking a 5lb. chicken using the included rotisserie settings.
The Hamilton Beach 31104 can fit two 12” pizzas, two 9×13 casserole dishes, or two cake pans simultaneously. If you’re looking for a countertop oven that packs a punch but can still fit easily in your kitchen, the Hamilton Beach 31104 could be the best choice for you.
5. Oster Extra Large Capacity Countertop 6-Slice Digital Convection Toaster Oven
If you want to completely take the guesswork out of setting your toaster oven to bake something, then consider the Oster.
Instead of knobs and dials, the Oster features a digital keypad, not unlike a contemporary microwave.
If you have arthritis or difficulty turning nobs, then this is one of the best toaster ovens for you.
This toaster oven is compact and has a temperature range of 200 to 450 degrees. You can set it to bake, toast, broil or defrost.
It takes very little time to heat up. Four minutes seems like its average warm up time.
It’s large enough to toast 14 slices of bread at once. This toaster stands up to the best of them.
The oven has an “easy clean” interior, and while it may not be non-stick, it’s still easy enough to clean.
And included in the Oster’s package is a baking pan and a broiling rack.
4. Americana ERO-2600BL Toaster Oven
Yes, another retro looking toaster oven makes our list! The Americana ERO-2600BL retro toaster oven is a great size. At 16.25 x 19.1 x 13.4 inches, it is small enough to fit on the counter and use instead of firing up your full-size oven and heat up the whole kitchen.
If you max out the 6 pieces of bread this toaster oven boasts it can handle at once, they will all come out evenly toasted because of the Even Heat Technology.
The 60-minute timer has a convenient Auto-Shut off feature and also has a Stay-On option if you need longer cooking time.
The oven door is not only fashionable, it is sturdy and reliable and is made of safety tempered glass. The door handle is made of sleek stainless steel.
The Americana retro toaster oven is easy to use and even comes with a recipe booklet.
3. Panasonic NB-G110P Flash Xpress
If you want something that cooks quickly and evenly, then you should buy the Panasonic FashXpress.
This too is energy efficient at 1300 watts. And has a higher temperature range than those ovens in our previous lineup.
This oven does take a while to heat up. But once it’s hot, it’s hot. The Panasonic FlashXpress uses a double infrared heating system using both quartz and ceramic heating to cook your food.
The oven uses a small display screen for the timer and temperature of the oven.
The Panasonic FlashXpress automatically turns off when the timer runs out. And with a 25-minute timer, this oven may not be for every kind of food you would like to cook.
But, it does come with six cooking presets: Toast, waffle, roll, pizza, reheat, and hashbrowns.
The 10 lb Panasonic will serve a lot of your needs if you’re looking for something fast and efficient but you don’t want to use it for larger dishes that take more time.
2. KitchenAid KCO273SS 12″ Convection Bake Digital Countertop Oven
This oven is quite large with two adjustable racks for two 12 inch pizza or whatever 12-inch dish you would like to cook.
The temperature ranges from 150 to 450 degrees. And it preheats faster than anything in our lineup so far.
If you want something that preheats in under three minutes. This would be your toaster.
Everything cooks evenly in this oven. And the programming in the oven is efficient enough to keep your food from overheating. The oven will shut off when the cycle is done.
The only negative to this toaster is the lack of an automatic rack ejection system.
1. Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven
We have smart cars, smart TVs, smartphones, and now we have a smart toaster oven. Our best smart toaster oven.
This oven only weighs 17 lbs. It can bake a 13-inch pizza or 6 slices of bread.
It has an insulated dual-wall door and glass window to keep all the heat in for efficiency.
It cooks at a minimum of 120 degrees and a maximum of 500 degrees.
It uses a combination dial and digital display. And it’s truly smart with nine preset functions and temperatures. And it includes a two-hour timer and shut-off feature. But this can be extended manually if need be.
As you can see, there are many options, styles, and sizes to consider when shopping for a toaster oven. While the Breville Smart Oven wins the Gold in our lineup, any toaster oven on this list should serve you well.